Browser game or app: what do you give up with each?

Updated on

A browser game gives up a little to skip the install: it opens from a link, is always the newest version and takes no room on the device, but it keeps your progress in the browser and needs a connection to start. An app gives up the link: it must be found in a store and installed before anyone plays, and it keeps its saves inside itself. Boomer Brawl is a browser game, so this page sets the two ways side by side.

The two side by side

A browser game runs in a tab without an install, while an app downloads from a store onto the device. Each way handles storage space, software updates, saved progress and game invites differently.

whata browser gamean app
installnothing: open the addressfind it in the device's store and install it
room on the devicethe browser's cache, which it may clearthe app's own size and its data
updatesthe newest version loads with the page, and a reload fetches itthrough the store, by itself or by hand, so two players may have different versions
savesin the browser's storage for that site, on that deviceinside the app, on that device, gone when the app is deleted
sharinga link opens the game, even straight into a friend's matcha link works only once the app is installed
where it runsany phone, tablet or computer with a browser that can draw itthe systems the app was made for

Installing, and room on the device

A browser game needs nothing installed: opening its address loads it into a tab, and closing the tab closes it. You never wait for an installer to finish, and you never manage files on your disk.

The first load fetches the game, and the browser keeps a copy so the next visit starts faster. The game's first load is about 23 to 25 MB; how much data a browser game uses has the rest. That cached data sits in temporary storage rather than claiming permanent room.

An app is found in the device's store and installed first, and it takes its room on the device until it is deleted. It remains in storage even when you do not play, occupying drive space until you remove it.

Updates and versions

A browser game is the newest version every time it loads, for everyone at once. There is no store review delay and no update screen to sit through before a round.

An app updates through its store, by itself or when the player chooses, so friends can end up on different versions. One person might have automatic downloads turned off, while another updated that morning.

In an online game two different versions often cannot play together until both are updated. In a browser game a reload fixes that.

Where the saves live

A browser game writes your progress into the browser's storage for its site, on that device. Your match records remain attached to that specific profile on that machine.

MDN Web Docs, Storage quotas and eviction criteria, says that what a private window stored is usually deleted when it closes, that Safari deletes the stored data of sites that are not used regularly, and that you can delete a site's data in the browser's settings. A private tab loses its stored data as soon as you close it. Regular browser cleanup routines can also erase those stored files.

An app keeps its saves inside itself, out of reach of a browser's clearing, but deleting the app deletes them too. The operating system keeps those files separate from regular web cache cleanups.

Some games keep progress on a server under an account, which follows you anywhere either way. That setup lets you log in from another machine without losing items. Does a browser game save progress has the details.

Sharing with friends

A browser game is a link: send it in a chat and a friend opens it with nothing to install first.

A link can carry more than the game: an invite into one match, so the friend lands in it. They join the lobby directly instead of typing a room name into a search box.

MDN Web Docs, Navigator: share() method, says a web page can hand a link to the device's own share sheet, though not in every browser. That lets you send a match address straight through your favourite messaging tool.

An app has to be installed by everyone before the first match, which is the slow part of any evening. If one player lacks the build, everyone waits while the store finishes the download.

What an app still does better

An app opens from its own icon without a browser around it. That leaves your full screen clear for the match and keeps browser controls out of view.

It keeps its saves when the browser's data is cleared. System cleanup routines or private browsing habits do not erase its local save files.

It is made for the systems it runs on, where a browser game depends on what the browser can draw: a game like this needs a browser that draws WebGL 2. Older software or unmaintained mobile browsers might fail to render the screen at all.

How Boomer Brawl does it

Boomer Brawl is a free top-down arena brawler that runs in the browser: open the game, and nothing is installed. You enter an arena round immediately without making an account or clearing drive space.

The host's share link, boomerbrawl.com/play/?join= followed by the code, opens the game straight on the Join tab with the code filled in. Your friends open the link and land in the lobby ready to fight.

Your progress is saved in the browser you play in; no account, no download says what that keeps and what it gives up. Boomer Brawl is a browser game with nothing to install: play a round.

Common questions

Does a browser game load all over again every time?

No. The first visit fetches the whole game, and after it the browser keeps a copy, so later visits fetch little.

Does a browser game need an internet connection?

Yes, to load it, and an online match needs one throughout.

Can a browser game save progress?

Yes. It saves in the browser on that device, but a private window or cleared site data wipes it.

Do browser games update by themselves?

Yes. Every load fetches the newest version, so there is nothing to update by hand.

Sources

Keep reading